Product Description
This volume papers both a initial mistakes and a changes in U.S. process that now offer genuine wish of success in Iraq. Although a United States accepted conjunction a critical conditions in Iraq, nor a value of Iraqi military, security, and troops army in fighting a flourishing insurgency, a republic undertook a array of process changes in Jun 2004 that might good scold these mistakes and emanate a kind of Iraqi army that are critical to both Iraq's destiny and any successful rebate in Coalition army and contingent withdrawal from Iraq.
In this book, Cordesman sets a series of U.S. process priorities that contingency be achieved if Iraqi army are to be combined during anything like a levels of strength and cunning that are required. He is assured that posterior a right module consistently and with a right resources might good attain in elucidate a confidence aspects of a nation-building problem in Iraq. The story of U.S. efforts to emanate Iraqi army is a warning that Americans during each turn need to consider about what fondness and team-work meant in formulating associated army for this kind of republic building and warfare. Iraq is usually one instance of how critical a purpose such army contingency play in many forms of uneven warfare. What is equally transparent is that Americans contingency know that they have a dignified and reliable shortcoming to a army they are creating.
Product Details
- Amazon Sales Rank: #2737839 in Books
- Published on: 2005-11-30
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 1.81 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 440 pages
Editorial Reviews
Review
"Iraqi Security Forces: A Strategy for Success chronicles a initial mistakes and changes of US process with honour to a origination and training of a efficient Iraqi confidence apparatus. Cordesman highlights a process changes intiated in Jun 2004, that directed to scold these past mistakes and to pave a approach for a rebate and contingent withdrawal of Coalition army from Iraq. The author sets out a series of US process prescriptions that he believes, if practical consistently and with a compulsory resouces, could assistance to stabilise Iraq."
-Middle East Journal
"Author, radio commentator, and someday US supervision agent, Cordesman argues that a US contingency erect Iraqi military, security, and troops army as an essential component of nation-building and stability, and presents a module for doing so. Most of a book is research of a formulation and execution of a 2003 US advance of Iraq and a successive function and rebellion to it. Then he looks during The Iraqi View, a elaborating inlet of a dispute and a risk of narrow-minded and racial conflict, before laying out his possess ideas in a final chapter."
-Reference & Research Book News
"Cordesman, who binds a Burke Chair in Strategy during a bipartisan Center for Strategic and International Studies, has constructed an research of a Iraq fight that is good written, entirely researched, and objective. The volume describes a rush to fight but committing adequate troops forces, a disaster to consider a inlet and distance of a Iraqi insurgency, and, maybe many importantly, a disaster to conflict to a wartime fall of Iraqi military, security, and troops forces. The rush to send supervision brought new problems; an choosing does not indispensably emanate a emperor government, or even a loyal democracy. In a author's analysis, a US set a theatre for a polite fight by not sufficient recruiting, training, and equipping troops and inhabitant ensure forces. Cordesman has supposing a text for this and destiny administrations on how not to control a fight and occupation; it includes a useful chronology of events. This work should be compulsory reading for professionals in a margin and anyone endangered about a miss of swell in Iraq. Essential. General readers, lower-division undergraduates by practitioners."
-Choice
By Anthony H. Cordesman
Buy new: $51.95
21 used and new from $11.94
Customer Rating: 
First tagged "strategy" by F. Malafarina "doglover"
Customer tags: anthony h cordesman, middle east, strategy, military, espionage, iraq war
Customer Reviews
Most useful patron reviews
2 of 2 people found a following examination helpful.
Iraqi Security Forces: A Strategy for Success
By Michael Rubin
Cordesman prolifically chronicles Middle Eastern troops affairs, and Iraqi Security Forces is a standard work for him with most information though small analysis. He does not discuss a motive for a Iraq war--what's past is past--but, with a advantage of hindsight, suggests that vital mistakes could have been avoided. Included on a prolonged list of bullet-points are failures to consider Iraqi nationalism accurately, to devise effective information operations, settle a municipal infrastructure compulsory for nation-building and post-conflict stability, and settle applicable systems of governance.
The strength of Cordesman's investigate lies in a transparent chronology of attempts to reconstruct Iraq's confidence forces. One chapter, for example, examines "coalition training and apparatus efforts" in 2003. The successive one outlines a disaster to broach adequate training and apparatus by a initial half of 2004, and a following one describes flourishing movement in efforts to sight a Iraqi troops (curiously, but mentioning then-lieutenant ubiquitous David Petraeus, who spearheaded such efforts).
But Cordesman's work has problems. It reads like a cover with contribution and sum cut-and-pasted, afterwards feeble integrated into a narrative. A section surveying Iraqi confidence and invulnerability views includes no Iraqi Arabic sources and usually a few quotes culled from a Western press. Nor does Cordesman make any use of prisoner Iraqi papers that might, for example, strew light on a expansion of a insurgency.
Some opinions are presented as fact, to his work's detriment; he is vicious of U.S. over-reliance on outcast groups, that he says lacked credit in Iraq but ever explaining because such outcast groups dominated each Iraqi election. If usually "internal" sum who remained in Iraq have legitimacy, does he warn partnership with Shi`i minister Muqtada al-Sadr, a usually such "internal" personality to emerge in post-Saddam Iraq?
Cordesman can also be imprecise. While he is scold to note that de-Baathification practical usually to a tip 4 tiers of celebration members, representing maybe 40,000 people out of dual million sum celebration members, he is wrong that these firqa' turn employees became Baathists usually for convenience, to validate for jobs. Achieving firqa' standing compulsory complicity in Baath operations. There are also vicious omissions, such as a deficiency of contention about prewar efforts to sight a Iraqi confidence army and a successive operations and formation of these Free Iraqi Forces.
Sloppiness with sources and citations is a problem. On page 3, for example, he reproduces most verbatim and but anxiety several paragraphs of an essay this reviewer published in 2005.[1] Although Cordesman does not intentionally plagiarize, this occurrence does advise oversight and an over-reliance on drifting investigate assistants. To Cordesman's and a publisher's credit, they are rectifying a problem and including a anxiety on a electronic chronicle of a content and all destiny editions. The miss of an index and bibliography make Iraqi Security Forces untimely to reference.
Iraqi Security Forces offers no earth ruinous solutions. Cordesman's recommendations--emphasis on force peculiarity and some-more courtesy to a police--are too ubiquitous to be valuable. So, too, are his broader asides on a need for improved process formation and a some-more clear U.S. grand strategy. Cordesman's works mostly review like compendiums, and this book, that offers small application to a journalist, academic, or process practitioner, is no exception.
Michael Rubin
Middle East Quarterly
Winter 2008
[1] Michael Rubin, "A Comedy of Errors: American-Turkish Diplomacy and a Iraq War," Turkish Policy Quarterly, Spring 2005.
No comments:
Post a Comment